by Roy Lukes

Determining The Age Of Grosbeaks Is A Challenge


The nesting season is nearing an end and birds, such as this rose-breasted grosbeak, will be more secluded as they molt all their feathers.

The rose-breasted grosbeaks have outwardly had a very good summer thus far in our woods. Now some of the young are feeding themselves and bathing regularly without coaxing from the adults.

Yesterday while photographing the activity at our platform feeders I watched a young male vibrate his wings very vigorously while "dad" shelled sunflower seeds nearby. Soon the youngster was fed, but dad moved to the far side of the feeding area.

Now I observed something that I had never seen before. The baby male, apparently fully capable of shelling his own seeds, continued to rapidly quiver his wings as he swallowed the seeds he himself had hulled.

The rose-breasted grosbeak surely is an ideal bird to study during its molting sequences. Bird banders classify birds seen after the first of the year as at least "After Hatch Year" or AHY. In other words, rose-breasted grosbeaks that we see during May, June and early July, when the young are still in the nest, are birds that were hatched last year or before.

They are all "AHY’s" or older. Knowing how the plumage of this species changes with the various molts one can go a step further in classifying these birds in spring. The flashy rose-breasted males sporting black crowns, black wings and black tails were hatched before last summer. They are at least third-year birds or older. We call them "After-Second-Year" birds, or ASY's.

The males that arrive here in spring sporting rosy breasts along with brown crowns, brown wings, and brown tails are males hatched last summer, or males in their second year. Our label for them is "SY," meaning second-year bird. All males, from the time they leave the nest, sport delicate pink under-wing linings, usually concealed when the bird is at rest. The under-wing linings of all of the females, from nestlings through adults, are yellow.

Females, unless you can observe them very carefully after they have left the nest, are very difficult to age. Being dark brown on the back and tail, tan with streaks on their breasts, their only real badges of femaleness are their yellow underwing linings. Immature males, aside from their rosy underwing linings, cannot be outwardly distinguished from the females, regardless of the age of the females.

The few exceptions in aging females come immediately after they have left the nest. They are innocently immaculate in appearance. Feather edges are clean and very sharply defined as opposed to the more ragged feather edges of the adult birds, and their food begging tactics are give-aways. They’ve got to be hatch-year birds, HY’s. Also, take a close look at the base of their beak and you will notice that the fold of skin there, between the upper and lower mandibles, is quite pinkish, a feature found on most hatchlings immediately after leaving the nest.

The adult male rose-breasted grosbeaks surely have a far-reaching, rich and lilting song that is incredibly pure in tone. It carries through the woods as soon as they arrive for the summer and continues throughout much of the nesting period. In fact the male is such an exuberant singer that he often sings while taking his turn incubating the eggs.

A good vocalization to learn is that of the baby grosbeaks upon leaving the nest and beginning to beg for food. It always sounds to us as though the young birds are repeatedly saying, "HEer, HEer, HEer."

Molting has already begun and is especially noticeable on the second-year males. They are looking downright ragged now, ungroomed, regular ragamuffins. Their breast feathers, while still containing plenty of rose coloring, are beginning to show tan edges and their brown wing and tail feathers are showing plenty of wear.

The adult males, still sporting their regal black, white and rose "suits" are now showing traces of tan on their backs. They are slowly losing their trim and sharp breeding plumage.

Regardless of how these grosbeaks differ in plumage, there remains one undeniably strong characteristic common to all – their bite! YIKES! They surely can bite! A person just can’t have a total concept of rose-breasted grosbeaks until you have held a live one in your hand and became careless enough to allow it to grab onto your finger. What a shock! What an agonizing vice-like grip, as though someone were pinching your finger with a pair of pliers until it bled. Yes, they drew blood from my fingers more than once during the 27 years that I banded birds!

All I can say is that the tortuous experience deepened my admiration for so magnificent a creature. We surely are fortunate that the rose-breasted grosbeaks are common nesters in bmany woods of northeastern Wisconsin.


This column appeared in the Door County Advocate on 08/02/2003.
© Copyright 2003 Roy Lukes. All rights reserved.