by Roy Lukes

Watching Cattle Egrets Can Make Good Comedy


Eight of the "natty nine" cattle egrets

Late November and early December have invariably produced interesting bird sightings in Door County largely on account of the many miles of shoreline. On the one hand, strong westerly storms have been known to push bohemian waxwings, varied thrushes and an occasional Townsend’s solitaire into the state. This year it’s the unusually warm weather that may be responsible for some species lingering here considerably later than usual.

Bob and Helen Mueller, friends living west of Baileys Harbor, reported five sandhill cranes in the field to the north of their home on Nov. 26. These are the greater sandhills, thousands of which are now congregating at the Jasper-Pulaski State Wildlife Area in northern Indiana.

Charlotte and I scoped Moonlight (Mud) Bay at Baileys Harbor this morning, Nov. 27, and counted 26 tundra swans. One, a young of the year, was quite gray and sported a rosy-pink bill. Seldom have we missed seeing these stately large white birds there at this time of the year. Hopefully there still may be some in the area for the Christmas bird counts in mid to late December.

Dean and Bernice Shumway, who live east of Sister Bay, reported a cattle egret on their lawn for the past few days. It’s been over 20 years since we’ve observed any of these interesting little herons in the county.

One of the most phenomenal occurrences in the history of North American birds created a great deal of excitement about 46 years ago. A small number of 20-inch-long cattle egrets were sighted in various places along the East Coast ranging from Florida to Newfoundland and even inland to the Chicago region. This marked the first time a new species arrived on this continent by its own accord and became well established.

Several friends and I thoroughly enjoyed our first sighting of them in the Horicon Marsh region in the early 1960’s. True to form, they were exhibiting their most renowned trait, searching for food in the company of cows. The large grazing animals were inadvertently flushing insects from the pasture while the tiny egrets scurried back and forth, often quite precariously beneath the cows’ hooves, catching their prey, including grasshoppers, crickets, etc. Occasionally one of the birds would even perch upon the back of one of the placid cows.

It was our friend, Tom Erdman of UWGB, who discovered the first nesting cattle egrets in Wisconsin in 1971. It was in Brown County, in the lower Green Bay area, in a large colony of black-crowned night herons where the two nests were observed. Five young were produced that year. Since then sizable colonies of these birds have been established in Oconto County, at the Horicon marsh and elsewhere.

It is still a mystery as to exactly how the first cattle egrets reached the Americas. Generally it is assumed that a flock became lost while flying along the northwest coast of Africa and was eventually aided by strong winds in reaching British Guiana. The coastal mangrove islands there suited these birds perfectly. Eventually they reached Central America and finally Florida, perhaps via the Gulf of Mexico. Many believe they arrived in the Sunshine State as early as 1948.

When a call came to me in early November of 1978 from Gordon Lodge, in northern Door County, telling of nine small pure white birds perched on their dock, immediately I thought, CATTLE EGRETS! Moments later my wish was fulfilled as we watched and photographed the hilarious antics of the "marvelous nine." Given little black derbies and moustaches we could just as well have been watching nine miniature two-winged Charlie Chaplins as they comically, in slapstick fashion, strutted around the dock appearing to be playing games in the gusty wind.

Roosts of as many as 30,000 cattle egrets in Florida today reflect the success of these stocky birds. Apparently there is slight competition between this dapper little egret and other native species. This is because the cattle egrets spend much of their time in open fields and uplands searching for insects rather than in marshes and wetland areas where the other species of herons and egrets feed.

Many birders of the Old World refer to this petite egret as the buff-backed heron. Pinkish buff feathers adorn the crown, back and lower neck of this bird during the breeding season. Then too its legs are a greenish yellow to dull reddish and its bill can vary from yellow to orange to reddish. Fall and winter find the plumage white, bill yellow and legs dark brown or blackish.

November is a likely time to see these rare transient visitors pausing for a rest on their way south for the winter. The magnitude of surprise shown by the initial sighting of the first cattle egret in the US was perhaps equaled by our thrill as we enjoyed the clownish parade of the "natty nine!"

Also see:


This column appeared in the Door County Advocate on 12/03/1999.
© Copyright 1999 Roy Lukes. All rights reserved.